James Bovard on the TSA & assorted comments

UPDATED BELOW.  

Do go over to Jim Bovard’s column at the Washington Times not only to read about his recent TSA experience (he and I have been in touch by email for a few years), but also to read the comment thread, where we have this wondrous gem of Aristotelian logic and Platonic beauty. It’s brought to you by “Harry Huntington”:

It is unfortunate that just as we face a heightened risk for terrorism this paper displays poor judgment to print an unsupported attack on TSA. TSA is one of the most effective agencies in the US government. How do we know this: since TSA was started there have been zero terrorist attacks on US airlines. That result is amazing. If planes were being bombed and hijacked there would be some reason to complain. That is not happening. We should be grateful that TSA is as good as it is and ask TSA to be even more vigilant. We also should consider using TSA to check all other forms of mass transit in the US: trains and busses. We likely also should use TSA to screen all cars traveling across state lines.

Ah, Harry. How lovely you are!

My response, by the way:

“TSA is one of the most effective agencies in the US government.”

Ha ha ha ha! Thank you, bless you, for giving me a hearty laugh this morning. I won’t bother presenting all the years’ worth of empirical evidence proving you wrong, because plenty of research shows that empirical evidence only causes people to dig their heels in further. I will only repost your comment far and wide so that others may share the joy.

I urge you all to pile on. (Warning that the page is full of annoying pop-up ads).

Photo courtesy of James Bovard

UPDATE: Honestly, I can’t tell anymore if “Harry” is serious or pulling our leg. After looking through his Disqus profile, I could go either way. But I think he’s being sarcastic. So hats off to you, Harry, and apologies for taking you seriously. You have to understand that we run into people all the time who would like nothing better than to expand the TSA and institute searches outside our front doors. And they’re not being sarcastic.